Will Renault Lodgy crush Toyota Innova?

If a benchmark existed for an MPV then it was the one set by the Toyota Innova for Indian markets. It’s ruled the roost for the better part of this century and continues to be the undisputed leader in the segment.  Undoubtedly a great product, but then where was the competition? The Xylo’s, Tavera’s, Sumos (in all its avatars) were crude also ran’s. The Ertiga’s and the likes a size and segment smaller and the SUV’s such as Tata Safari and the Mahindra XUV were well SUV’s weren’t they….

That was until now. Enter the Dragon Slayer, the buzz of the automotive world, the “Lodgy” from Renault.  Let’s not pay too much attention to that dodgy little name more apt for a run-down motel in a faraway place, and focus on what the real thing is like.
Front Happy Grill
 At first glance it’s a kind of an odd ball in looks a pleasant face with an oversized body. But then the looks really grow on you and after hanging around near the Lodgy for a little bit, I actually found nothing unpleasant at all. It looks best from the front with a dominant chromed grill and swept back headlights. The side views are van-like and uninspiring (the small 15” wheels don’t help). A bulging tail lamp at the rear finishes a motley medley of looks that in the end all add up to a glued eye.
Interior View from Rear Seat
The insides are where all the actions is. It’s got a lot of space for sure. Simplistically seats seven/eight in three rows. The best place to be is the front row with beautifully finished seats which are really a nice place to be planted on for a long drive or even a dash to your local barber. The second row is the functional row, comfortable with hatch-back like legroom. (I wish the middle row had a slider which could have released even more space if the third row wasn’t used)
Console


The third row is, well, not as comfortable as the Innova, and you sit with your knees high up. But good leg room even here. You can carry some decent sized bags with all three rows in use.  With very flexible seating,   a fold and tumble third row (which also can be removed with some effort), and a tumble second row, the Lodgy can turn into a mobile warehouse with which you can comfortably move your house and perhaps take your neighbour’s dog along if you do choose to.


Overall, a very spacious offering. The ergonomics are good all around and the plastics and materials used visually appealing. Most switches and buttons are where you would expect to find them and that’s a good thing. (That must create envy for some Duster owners)

Driving the Lodgy is also a pleasant experience. It comes with the 1.5L K9 diesel engine with two states of tune - 85 BHP and 110 BHP. I drove the 110BHP version which comes mated to a six-speed manual transmission. The engine is quiet and refined.  There is a noticeable turbo lag at lower speeds and therefore city driving will require frequent downshifting to second and first gears. I wish the gear ratio was better spaced to enhance city driveability.

Once you do get past the 1800 RPM band, life is good. The Lodgy is an effortless mile muncher and an excellent highway hero. The gears are precise and the clutch light. The icing on the cake is the suspension setup which handles beautifully in most situations. In bone rattling terrain such as Bangalore, the Lodgy did well gliding over road humps and potholes without knocking off any dentures. The braking is also safe and predictable.

I came away from the test drive rather impressed. It appears to be a well-rounded package for an MPV seeker.  It runs the Innova rather close and importantly will save you a few lakh rupees. So at long last a challenger may have arrived which could upstart the leader one vehicle at a time.


(Sandeep Sahadevan is an auto enthusiast and anything on wheels moves him. Write to him for advice at editor@northbangalorepost.com or northbangalorepost@gmail.com)

Comments